- | Mercatus Podcasts Mercatus Podcasts
- | Ideas of India Ideas of India
- |
Abhinav Ghosh on the role of NGO workers in Education Policy and Delivery in India
Ghosh and Rajagopalan discuss the role of NGOs in implementing education policy, how NGO workers navigate relationships with government officials and teachers, and the challenges of building state capacity in India.
Shruti Rajagopalan: Welcome to Ideas of India, a podcast where we examine academic ideas that can propel India forward. My name is Shruti Rajagopalan, and this is the 2026 job market series, where I speak with young scholars entering the academic job market about their latest research on India.
I spoke with Abhinav Ghosh who is a Postdoctoral Fellow at the Center for Education Policy Research and received his Ph.D. in Education at Harvard University. We discussed his job market paper titled, “The Implicit Bureaucrats: NGOs and Policy Implementation in India.”
We talked about the role of NGOs in education policy in India, when and how NGO workers align and distance themselves from the state, implementing India’s Foundational Literacy and Numeracy Mission NIPUN, and much more.
For a full transcript of this conversation, including helpful links of all the references mentioned, click the link in the show notes or visit mercatus.org/podcasts.
Hi, Abhinav. Welcome to the podcast. It’s such a pleasure to have you here.
Abhinav Ghosh: Hi, Shruti. It’s an absolute pleasure being here as a long-time listener of the podcast. Really, really feeling great to be a participant now.
Exploring the Role of NGO Workers in Education Policy Implementations
Rajagopalan: I’m so thrilled to hear that then. So, welcome. I really enjoyed reading your paper. There’s a lot of economics of education and a lot of development economists looking at education, but yours is actually a very different approach than what those papers usually take, so, I really enjoyed reading it.
In this particular paper, you ask how NGO employees go on to do work of government, which is policy implementation, without actually being government employees. You’re studying the implementation of a particular program called NIPUN, which is India’s Foundational Literacy and Numeracy Mission. Through a qualitative, collective case study with one government partner NGO in three districts across north India, and over a period of a couple of years between 2023 and 2025, you shadow 10 district-level workers, and you interview them repeatedly. And you observe their interactions with officials who are working in government, with the teachers in schools, training sessions, government meetings.
And from these recurring interviews and also watching what’s going on, you identify three recurring approaches to getting policy implemented, which I thought were really striking. What I took from your findings is that these workers don’t just bring technical expertise to the system; there is something a little bit more layered and interesting going on.
They invoke government authority to get certain kinds of tasks which are administrative and to get those completed. But they also distinguish themselves from government inspectors when they’re engaging with teachers. When they’re engaging with teachers, they’re not coming at them from above. It’s more of a persuasion exercise. They also routinely emphasize their limited technical responsibilities when government officials raise problems. These could be resource problems or teacher shortages, and so on.
You call these authoritative enforcement, entrepreneurial persuasion, and strategic depoliticization. And what I believe is your central argument is that the same workers can draw on the state’s authority or distance themselves from it depending on what they are trying to accomplish and given who they are engaging with.
And this, of course, brings up a number of questions such as the role of the state, the role of parastatal entities, the role of intermediaries who are working with the state, and how we think about all of these questions in the broader policy formulation and policy implementation landscape. So, first up, did I roughly get what you’re trying to do about right? And what made you work on this?
GHOSH: Amazing. Thank you so much. Yes, I think spot on. Pretty much, you get at the heart of the argument that I’m making here. And I think a lot of this actually dates back to when I actually started my dissertation research—which was, as you identified, largely around understanding how the implementation of NIPUN Bharat, which is India’s flagship policy on achieving foundational literacy and numeracy—how does the implementation of that look like on a day-to-day basis, at a ground level?
And so, a lot of the motivation for this paper actually emerged when I was doing fieldwork. There would be these times when I would venture into government offices at a block or a district level in order to understand how the bureaucrats there are engaging with the policy. And I would always see there would be this one or two people there who did not look like they were government officials right there, right? They had these different bags. They were branded, obviously, with the logos of the NGOs that they were working for.
And I think over time, as I did this work across two or three states, I realized that it was a pretty common occurrence where a lot of these NGO representatives at a local level were present in some of these regional government offices. I was really interested in what they were doing there, how they were participating in the implementation of this large policy.
I think besides this practical motivation, there’s also an academic motivation to do this work. I think two of my favorite recent works on education and education policy implementation are Akshay Mangla’s book, Making Bureaucracy Work, and then Yamini Aiyar’s book recently, Lessons in State Capacity. Both fantastic books, making really, really interesting arguments. I think because those books make such really important contributions to understanding policy implementation in India, Indian education specifically, I was actually struck by how those books don’t really capture the role of NGOs that were involved in the respective contexts that they study.
So, Akshay—I think one of the chapters is on Bihar, and he’s talking about Teaching at the Right Level being implemented there. The key actors in Akshay’s stories are actually the bureaucrats there, and not, let’s say, Pratham representatives. Similarly, Yamini is talking about the Delhi context, where a lot of the Mission Buniyaad work that she refers to is actually based on Pratham’s own models.
So, I think somewhere I felt that policy implementation literature, in general, in Indian education, has treated NGOs as peripheral actors. They’ve never been the centerpiece of it. And yet, as I found out through the course of this study, they were pretty much bang in the center of it. They were taking decisions that actually had a lot of impact on some of these policy implementation structures. So, I think that’s where I got into this research.
It had to be a qualitative research, in my opinion, mostly because I feel some of these NGO-state partnerships at a state level are often not very transparent. I wasn’t sure what the extent of their involvement was on a formal level. I felt somewhere, methodologically, I actually had to be on the ground to observe what is going on on a day-to-day level in order to make sense of some of this involvement.
Yes, I think broadly, and as you summarized, in terms of the findings, besides some of the three approaches that you outlined, in terms of authoritative enforcement, entrepreneurial persuasion, and then strategic depoliticization—and we’ll get to this, I hope, later. But I think one key thing was what you pointed out. The boundaries between a state and nonstate actors—and specifically, in this case, NGOs—they are much more porous. Oftentimes, we’ve heard of nonstate, like the word “non” gaps off them from the state. But I found that that wasn’t really true. These nonstate actors were really embedded within the state hierarchy. Often, opting for the very mechanisms that the state uses to get things done.
How NGOS Are Embedded in the Education System
RAJAGOPALAN: Yes. I want to get into that whole nonstate actor a little bit more later. But for those who are unfamiliar, maybe you could start us off by telling us what NGOs actually do in the Indian public education because they’re involved in many, many different ways.
Sometimes they’re literally provisioning education. Sometimes they are running additional remedial educational work to support whatever the state schools are doing. Sometimes they’re only providing money for those who can’t afford some of these educational programs. And sometimes they are doing what you’re talking about, which is this very interesting and layered interface in determining how the state actually delivers education and how state actors who are either part of the delivery or teachers, who are part of the workers working there, are shaping how education gets delivered.
Can you walk us through that? Because it’s a lot of different things, and I imagine it varies quite widely. But especially in your study, what does that look like?
GHOSH: Yes, no, definitely. I think it’s really important context to give for this study. If you have to talk about NGOs and their role in Indian education, that’s probably a separate podcast episode, but I’ll try to briefly cap in what the lay of the land is.
Let me preface that by saying that a recent report by Dasra and Kearney, they outline that roughly 20 percent of all registered NGOs in India work in education or early childhood. It’s the highest for any sector in India. I say that data point just to outline how involved NGOs in India are specifically in the field of education.
I think interestingly—I was talking to this one teacher during my fieldwork, and she was a veteran. She had been teaching for 25 years, and I think she really succinctly captured it. She was like, “Early on in my career, these NGO people would come, and they would distribute sweaters to children. Then over time, they would come and give out computers. Then one day they came in and just did assessments with the children. And now suddenly I have textbooks that feature the NGO logo.” I felt that comment was so succinctly capturing the shift in NGO involvement in education from a teacher’s perspective.
RAJAGOPALAN: Absolutely.
GHOSH: I think NGOs have played a lot of different roles, right? If we go back in time to the ’70s and ’80s, a lot of the NGOs were functioning more as advocacy organizations in education. They were doing a lot of community mobilization, ensuring children are going to schools, working through a very rights-based framework.
In the ’90s, once liberalization happens, there’s a lot of international money that flows into India, aid money that flows. A lot of projects get started, so District Primary Education Program (DPEP), one of the famous ones. World Bank puts an investment there. I think NGOs at that point take up this role of being technical contractors. They are supplementing the state in rolling out some of these large-scale programs that are happening.
I think as time passes, in 2000s, once Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan starts, Right to Education comes in, the state is now actively looking for people to supplement its services because the state realizes that it probably doesn’t have the entire bandwidth and resources to pull off what it’s promised. So, that’s when NGOs start getting involved into starting schools of their own or helping out in service provision in education in some way or the other.
And I think more recently, in the 2010s and then 2020s, you have the Companies Act that gets passed, so CSR becomes a thing, a major thing in India. Philanthropies and international donors, they start bypassing the low-capacity state and investing into these NGOs in order to get things done, right? You have this shifting political economy of NGOs over time in India. I think that then flows into what I’m getting at.
NGOs are now more involved in that policy and program-setting work. They are working more closely with the government than, let’s say, independent of the government. Emily Clough has a book coming out in the near future. It’s on NGOs and service provision in Indian education. She provides a really useful typology of these NGOs: advocacy NGOs, service-provision NGOs, and then partnered-provision NGOs. I think the names are pretty self-explanatory. My interest is in the third one, the partnered-provision one. So, what happens when NGOs are actually partnering with the state to roll out state service in this case?
I think it also brings into question a larger musing around civil society. A lot of NGOs still identify as civil society organizations, but I sometimes wonder what it means in light of close associations with the government and being funded through international donor networks. How independent and autonomous are NGOs really in India right now?
I think, broadly, this is the lay of the land with respect to NGOs. I think with respect to this paper, I had done some earlier work with a colleague of mine, Tanushree Sarkar. We had written this paper that got published around how NGOs were closely involved in formulating NIPUN as a policy. And I think there’s a lot of literature that captures nonstate actor role in policy-setting. But, as I make a case in this paper, that it’s not just the policy-setting where NGOs are involved in, but now they’re very much in the implementation team.
Examining the Role of "EduFirst" in Implementation
RAJAGOPALAN: No, that’s super helpful. That brings us to a point where we can jump into the implementation part. You are studying a very specific program, which is NIPUN. You’re also looking at a very specific NGO, which is EduFirst and its workers. So, what is NIPUN really, in terms of what is the program and what is the program asking of government officials? And where do EduFirst’s workers fit into this interface between what officials are doing for NIPUN and what the students need to receive?
GHOSH: Yes. No, that’s a really important question. So, again, I think for listeners, full clarity and disclosure, EduFirst is not a real name for the NGO. It’s a pseudonym—
RAJAGOPALAN: Yes.
GHOSH: —that I use— in order to anonymize.
RAJAGOPALAN: Sorry, I should have mentioned that.
GHOSH: No. Thanks. No worries. [chuckles] I also anonymize the state, actually, which is Vidyapur in this case. And so, both pseudonyms in order to protect respective actors involved in this study. Going back to NIPUN—NIPUN basically envisions—
RAJAGOPALAN: But NIPUN is an actual government program. Just FYI.
GHOSH: NIPUN is an actual government program. [laughter] You can look it up. It’s very much in the news right now because when NIPUN was launched in 2021, it had this overall goal that by 2026, 2027, which is right now, the goal of the mission was to achieve 100 percent foundational literacy and numeracy amongst primary grade children. What that means is that all children in primary grades should be able to read basic texts and do basic math problems, right?
I think something like the ASER report over the years has repeatedly shown that basic learning outcomes in India have been really poor. And so, I think NIPUN takes off from there after a culmination of a lot of advocacy from a lot of these organizations and commits itself to ensuring that everyone within the education system is motivated and committed towards achieving this goal of universal FLN.
In terms of what the policy entails, I think there are three key pillars. One is the usual teacher training, so rigorous professional development of teachers. I think the second is providing teachers with more structured teacher guides in order to teach, and also teaching aids, so, literal materials that teachers can use to teach. And then the third, which I feel is somewhat the more new part of this reform in some way, is a frequent data monitoring infrastructure, which then ensures a constant lifetime update of the entire state and its outcomes while also ensuring accountability in some way.
I think the way NIPUN delegates these responsibilities to states is that states are free to create their own version of the NIPUN mission, given education is a concurrent item. Then states appoint at a district level, states have a program, like a PMU, a project management unit, that runs the entire thing in the state. They delegate it to districts, to blocks, to clusters, and so on down the way to schools. So, even though officials at district and block levels are mostly doing monitoring, supervision, these kind of roles, at the end of the day, it’s the teachers and principals in schools who have to use these materials and teacher guides to create some kind of instructional change.
Now, where does EduFirst come into this? In the state of Vidyapur, in this case, EduFirst partners with the Vidyapur government. The public-facing announcement of that partnership is just that EduFirst is going to be the implementing partners for NIPUN in the state of Vidyapur. That’s about it. We don’t know much about what EduFirst is going to be involved in or the extent to which they’re going to be involved in. And that’s probably representative of a lot of these MOUs that tend to happen.
If you open LinkedIn on a fine day and just open some of the accounts of these really prominent education NGOs, there is a lot of MOU-signing happening, but there’s not much clarity exactly in terms of concretely what’s going on. I think based on my observations and some of EduFirst’s disclosure around what they have been doing, three things: One is they are responsible for some of the curricular aspects of it, so providing those teaching guides or teacher materials that I spoke about. They’re responsible for the teacher training part of it, so, coordinating a training, organizing what teachers will be trained on, and so on. I think the third part is something around—broadly sits between the space of data monitoring and overall coordination. Some of these NGOs are providing data infrastructures in terms of apps or dashboards where states can actually enter and then observe lifetime data. Some of them are just coordinating and ensuring that data is entered into this or not.
To go back to your question, I think there’s not much clarity on what exactly some of these NGOs, including EduFirst, are supposed to do, which makes me more interested in, “What does that look like in practice?”
Because I think very early on, I was really struck by the fact that there was this meeting room and the EduFirst representative walks in, and these two block-level officers behind me literally referred to him as “FLN wala,” Foundational Literacy and Numeracy wala. That was really interesting to me on how this NGO representative becomes a policy wala, in their language. So, that was really interesting and kicked things off.
Policy Walas
RAJAGOPALAN: Just to follow up on this last point, they become a kind of policy wala. I know the MOUs are varied and quite opaque, but what is the expertise that they bring, or is it not expertise but some legitimacy and trust? What is it that these NGO workers are really bringing to the table, or what are they perceived as bringing to the table for both the teachers and the government officials?
GHOSH: Yes, yes, that’s a really, really important question. I come to this answer as someone who has experience working with education NGOs in the past in India. I think there are two ways about it. One is that NGOs don’t get meritocratically selected to sign an MOU with the state. It’s not that the states are releasing a tender inviting applications from these different NGOs and then deciding who to partner with.
A lot of it is actually happening through relationship-building, pitching, meetings, networks, connections, funding, and these channels, right? So, that’s the part where conversations begin. I think with respect to expertise, that’s a more gray area. I don’t think people who are organizing the signing of the MOUs at the state level are pedagogical experts to verify whether these NGOs actually have the pedagogical expertise they are signing their MOUs for or not.
But I think there’s a lot of culture signaling that happens at some of these levels, right? A lot of the NGO leadership are urban, English-speaking, often educated at elite universities in India and abroad, have some experience, or sometimes vast amounts of experience, in corporate or even in the education sector. I think a lot of these actually signal expertise in a soft way, I would say, to people at the state level who then end up signing some of these MOUs. I think some of the expert-signaling happens right at the top where MOUs get signed, but that then trickles down all the way to these grassroots workers, as I call them, who are then liaising with actors at a ground level.
RAJAGOPALAN: Yes. When you start following these workers—or rather, tracking them. I didn’t want to make you sound like [laughter] a stalker. So, I guess I should say, when you start tracking these workers, is it with the intention of unpeeling the opacity, or is it with the intention of just simply understanding how these everyday embedded interactions work? Sorry, that’s a slightly clumsily phrased question, but the reason I’m asking is, is the part that is unclear to both state and teachers about what actually needs to be done? Or is the part that is unclear is how it needs to be done, and there are certain things the state actors are simply not able to do? What is it that you look at when you’re actually tracking these people daily? Not daily, but over a period of time?
GHOSH: Sure. Yes. No. I think both to some extent. The opacity part is definitely important. As I said, these MOUs are not transparent in any way, so we really don’t know what should be the scope of involvement and what extent they are actually involved. I think at the same time, a lot of studies of NGOs tend to happen top-down, so oftentimes NGO leadership is approached, conversations start there, and from a research standpoint, the leadership then organizes for, I don’t know, field visits and field work and stuff like that.
I oftentimes feel like NGO leadership, with the best of their intentions, are somehow constrained in a lot of ways to provide really polished, curated responses. They’re very PR-facing and fit for an elevator pitch somewhere. I think I wanted more raw data, right? I wanted to see, once the MOU gets into process and it comes down to that stubborn teacher or apathetic bureaucrat sitting, and this NGO worker approaches them and they have to pull off what has never happened before, what does that conversation look like? What does that discussion look like?
And at the same time, does that conversation go into where things in Indian education governance have historically gone, where not much has happened, or does that actually provide us some insights for where things can go from here? Is there something to learn in a way these NGO workers are mediating some of their day-to-day policy activity, which provides us a new way of approaching bureaucratic capacity?
So, I think for the same reasons that oftentimes when we study policy implementation, we don’t interview or shadow policymakers, but actually the bureaucrats. I think for similar reasons, as I’m studying NGO involvement in policy implementation, I wanted to start off with these grassroots workers who are employed at a local level. They are often hired from these local settings. Oftentimes not from Tier-1, Tier-2 cities. They’re from small towns. They’ve worked with multiple NGOs before in those spaces.
And I think they bring to the table a different kind of skillset than the NGO leadership. So, what does it mean for these people who don’t have much technical expertise in education but are still placed at a regional office to make sure that things get done? It requires a completely different set of skills, and that’s what I was fascinated by.
RAJAGOPALAN: No, and that’s actually—sorry, the question was far more clumsy than the answer, but that really gets to it, right? This fact that it’s not just the state that’s opaque, but leadership even in NGOs can be quite opaque. [laughter] Right? And so, it’s not just a state versus nonstate actor, but exactly who is doing what within this—
GHOSH: Exactly.
RAJAGOPALAN: —view that starts mattering, which you’ve tracked actually really well. Of all the papers that I read this year for the job market series, yours has my favorite beginning because it literally begins—it’s not one of those “this paper studies education policy in India” kind of beginning.
It’s actually a dialogue or an exchange that happens in a conference room between someone called Manish and an official. And the opening scene really is an NGO worker who is telling government officials that they need to comply. That I found very interesting because that’s what made me immediately want to read the rest of the paper, because that is not the way normally a nongovernment worker interfaces with a state worker.
Where is this authority coming from? Because the MOUs, as you already pointed out, are little bit flimsy and vague and opaque. So, where is this ability to complain or hold them to account or asking them to comply with a particular set of actions, where is that really coming from?
GHOSH: Yes. Thank you, firstly, for your really kind words. I still think about that dialogue that opens the paper. It was actually the first time during analysis that I came across that anecdote, and I was like, “Wow, wait, there’s something going on here.” That then motivated this entire paper. I think from my end as a writer, it was just fitting that I started the paper with that thing, something that kicked it off for me itself.
I do want to clarify one thing here. I think there are two kinds of authority. One is explicit authority where you have a formal designation in the system. You are in a position to give others orders and ask them to comply. You have incentives or consequences in case they don’t comply. That is a more formal, explicit form of authority that I think a lot of senior bureaucrats in the Indian education system have.
The kind of authority that I highlight with respect to some of these NGO grassroot workers is more implicit. None of them are bureaucrats. None of them are formally appointed to be within the state system. And yet they can—and actually end up—making things happen by asking people to do something and then holding them accountable.
I think there are a lot of mechanisms that actually grant them this implicit authority, and very small things. I think this is where some of that deep qualitative research really helped me uncover. Something as simple as when the state circular comes in, or there’s a training PowerPoint presentation, you often see the logos of these NGOs somewhere, here or there. It makes it look like how the NGO’s straight up there with the official authorities. When junior bureaucrats or schoolteachers or principals are reading these circulars or watching these presentations, it signals to them how important these NGO people are.
At the same time, I think most of these NGOs are actually headquartered in Tier-1 urban cities like the Delhis, Bombays, and Bangalores. And so, a lot of these regional workers, they don’t really have an office where they sit and work. This I find really fascinating across all states I’ve studied, but especially in Vidyapur, that the district-level education office or the block-level education office is where these actors actually have a table and a chair to sit and do their work. When teachers or bureaucrats come to meet them, they’re not going to an NGO office to meet them, but they are actually coming into an official government office to meet these people.
I think a lot of these small incidents or occurrences actually provide that implicit authority, which I think the NGO grassroots workers are aware of, and they leverage that. When a grassroots worker like Manish is telling someone that this is an order from above and you need to do four visits this week, the recipient listens to it, not just as an external authority coming and telling me something, but it’s actually someone who sits with the district education officer who’s coming in and telling me that I have to do it. That drives compliance in that case.
So, I think in some ways what I see is that—I think Akshay’s work really nicely shows how India has this legalistic, bureaucratic culture, where rule-driven, compliance-driven, things get done by the state. I think some of these NGO workers early on sense that. They actually leverage that is what I find. They actually leverage some of these legalistic guidelines to actually get things done amongst bureaucrats. I think to some extent, some of that actually derives from how they perceive these bureaucrats.
I think in follow-up interviews with some of these grassroot workers, they were pretty open in saying that if these people—and they say it in Hindi: “[Hindi language]” “Apni kursi ka kaam karte toh sab theek hota.” Basically saying that if they did what they’re supposed to do, everything would be great. So, I think somewhere they view these bureaucrats stereotypically as inefficient, apathetic, lazy. I think some of this hard-faced use of bureaucratic norms, legalistic norms to get things done, I feel stems from there. Yes. I think somewhere these actors then just fit into the system by co-opting what the system usually runs on.
Class, Connections, and Perception of NGO Workers
RAJAGOPALAN: This is less coming from your paper and a little bit more coming from my lived experience in India and engaging with all these various actors. I also feel like there is a layer of class and eliteness in this. As you pointed out, a lot of these NGOs are usually headquartered in a big city. They’re usually run by the wife of a civil servant or someone who has studied abroad, or the people who are doing the evaluations are the kids of very elite people. Often, I call it the “Madam Ji syndrome”. [laughter] Like, when people like me go to one of these district-level offices, we are called “Madam Ji”.
I wonder if there is some element of legitimacy and accountability just coming from there. Because it’s not like people who are parents of the students in school or the schoolteachers or one of the workers who is local is not able to tell them that, “Hey, this is the rule book, and this is what you’re supposed to follow.”
But when it is “upar se order hai” [transl: these are orders from above] or some mandate that came from New Delhi or above or the state capital or some fancy civil servant, then it is much more likely to be followed. And that makes this so much more cynical and, in some sense, more depressing. But did you feel any layer of that? Or am I completely misreading this because the 10 people you actually followed are local to the district?
GHOSH: With respect to the participants in this study, I did not see much of that because I feel—except three out of the 10 participants in this study, everyone was from Vidyapur. They were local to Vidyapur. I think their familiarity with the Hindi diction that is local to the state made it very clear to every bureaucrat involved that they were locals, right?
RAJAGOPALAN: Right.
GHOSH: I think the class aspect is really interesting here because I think somewhere these NGO grassroots workers were probably from similar or maybe lower socioeconomic classes as these lower-level bureaucrats as well. I think somewhere there was a shared level of kinship in some way. I’ll come to that when I talk about the next aspect of the finding. But I feel what you’re getting at is actually a symptom of one level above, maybe at a state level where that actually tends to operate.
I often—I have personally firsthand seen where NGO representatives at a state management level will go to the state education office. I think there is a class element. They’ll walk in with these laptops, they’ll open the laptop as they sit in a meeting. Some of them will have, I don’t know, black-framed glasses. Some will have a goatee. They’ll have something, a branded T-shirt, maybe. Some of these small, small things signal to the average, onlooking bureaucrat that, in Hindi terms, “Ye ache ghar ka hai” - they come from a good household.
I think those do operate at a higher echelon in the education system to signal that legitimacy and expertise. Again, not to say that necessarily means that NGO workers don’t have expertise. I think some of them are really skilled and adept at what they do. But I agree with your assessment that I think somewhere class does have a role to play, but as I preface it, it’s probably at a higher level than these grassroots workers.
Entrepreneurial Persuasion: Supporting Teachers in Policy Implementation
RAJAGOPALAN: Now you’re looking at government officials and the NGO workers. We discussed how they interface with the state officials, but they take a very different approach when they are working with teachers. That was the other super interesting thing to see through your paper. Here, instead of instructing them or holding them to account or throwing the rule book at them the way you see in the opening scene, this is more an exercise of persuasion or support or—actually, more support than anything else. So, what is really going on when they interface with teachers?
GHOSH: Yes. I’m glad you bring up the opening scene again and again, because I think it’s such a powerful representation of what I’m trying to get at. The NGO worker in that opening scene, Manish—pseudonym again. Manish is talking to an administrative bureaucrat in that conversation and really using the rule book to be like, “No, sir, you have to do four visits a week because that’s what “upar ka order” [transl: order from above] says.”
The same Manish, I capture him in an interaction with a teacher in a completely different setting where the teacher is like, “Sir, I can’t make that meeting that you’ve scheduled on Saturday because I’m the only teacher in my school and I can’t leave my kids and come.”
It’s so interesting because a part of me expects Manish to be like, “No, upar se order hai, it is an order, and you have to do it.” Suddenly, you have Manish saying that, “That’s all right, madam, maybe we can schedule a WhatsApp call later, and I’ll walk you through the main points in that meeting.”
I think during fieldwork, it just dropped upon me right at that time. I was like, “Wow, this is really interesting where he’s really using a completely different approach with this.” I think in a later conversation with Manish, he says that teachers need both monitoring and mentoring. In Hindi, he says that “monitoring toh state karta hai, mentoring hum karte hai”. He says the monitoring is the job of the state. That’s how the state has done things. We try to do the mentoring part.
I think it becomes really evident over the course of this paper that specifically in dealing with teachers—and I think NGO grassroots workers are aware that the task that teachers have to do is more complex than, let’s say, the average bureaucrat has to do. This goes back into, I think, a couple of great papers. One, definitely—I keep talking about Akshay’s book because it’s so brilliant, but I think he makes a typology of implementation tasks. He calls them complex tasks, intensive tasks, and then codifiable tasks. I think a lot of research in the past—I think there’s a fantastic paper by Yamini Aiyar and Shrayana Bhattacharya, “The Post Office Paradox,” which talks about how the average administrative bureaucrat is just spending a lot of time just passing down orders, right?
I think somewhere these grassroots workers realize that that’s what these administrative bureaucrats do. And so, their job is more doing with complying, and that’s where the use of legalistic norms with them comes from. But at the same time, these grassroots workers realize that what teachers have to do is instructional change. At the end of the day, the success of NIPUN eventually comes down to what happens in the classroom. And I think there is a certain amount of cautiousness but also good faith that these workers then place on teachers. I think that’s where some of this, what I call entrepreneurial persuasion comes in from.
So, instead of really imposing on teachers that, “This is how you have to do things,” they try and highlight the values of what they are asking teachers to do. They’ll bring a textbook, and they’ll be like, “Madam, this is a really scientifically designed textbook. The scope of sequence, it’s been designed by experts. If you teach, you produce really good results in your classroom and so on.” And at the same time, they are being lenient with teachers with respect to some of these rigid administrative burdens that they have.
So, I think from a vantage point of a teacher, you historically have had these supervisors or block-level officers who’ve come in and just told you what to do and then asked you not to do stuff outside your teaching role. And suddenly you have these NGO representatives coming in and be like, “You take your time. That’s all right. Here, let me suggest you something. Let me try to convince you of something.” That’s a complete shift in who’s liaising with them. I think somewhere there is where I find a lot more persuasion and coaxing going on on behalf of the NGO workers.
RAJAGOPALAN: It infused some optimism in me because when I think about what’s going on with the education system, the problem has always been this extra detailing of inputs and mandating inputs in this very precise way, almost like “upar se order aaya hai” [transl: these are orders from above], but not so much focusing on the output or the outcome eventually. That has been the huge effort more broadly of people who are looking at education in India, saying, “Hey, we really need to think about outcome.”
This is a program which is specifically geared towards delivering a certain outcome, which is this minimal literacy and numeracy. And it’s becoming quite clear that an additional mandate of inputs is not going to get you that. You need some level of flexibility. You need some additional support. Something needs to change to make that teacher more present, to make that teacher a better teacher, to equip them with more of whatever they need to deliver in the classroom, and then that’ll eventually hopefully turn into some kind of outcome. I can very clearly see that he’s focused much more on inputs with the government official and much more on output with the schoolteacher. And that flexibility is very interesting to watch. You actually show us that through conversation almost.
GHOSH: No, I’m glad you point that out because I think to some part, some of that does come from, potentially—again, this is not beyond the scope of my paper—but potentially some of that does come from a broad NGO guideline itself on how to deal with government employees and how to deal with teachers—
RAJAGOPALAN: Of course.
GHOSH: —where teachers are this powerful political faction that needs to be very cautiously treated with. But I think some of that is what I then argue is a very individual decision-making, right? That is where some of these grassroots workers are using a very unique skillset of mediating – getting things done with different kinds of actors using different approaches. That’s what I’m getting at through the paper, yes.
Navigating Resource Contraints
RAJAGOPALAN: I wanted to get into one more aspect of being resource-constrained. There is some stuff in the paper on actually how you navigate a particular kind of resource constraint where it’s shortage of materials, like the textbooks didn’t arrive on time, or other things didn’t show up on time.
This is actually a very interesting setting because now this is no longer just someone is too lazy to do their job or someone is unable to do their job or there is a particular manual. That’s the third element of your overall paper, which is about this kind of strategic depoliticization. Can you walk us through that? Because that’s another very interesting layer of what’s going on.
GHOSH: Yes. I think it’s a third facet that slightly deviates out of these first two pillars that I spoke about, which are authoritative enforcement and entrepreneurial persuasion. In that, I think the first use of rules scenario, the NGO’s almost acting like the state. They’re acting as formal state authorities. But I think in the teacher case where there’s more persuasion involved, they’re almost distinguishing themselves from the state where they’re like, “Oh, the state does the monitoring, we do the mentoring.” That kind of an approach.
I think this third part is where they’re neither acting like the state or differing from the state. They’re just acting as these neutral bystanders who are just there to help, and then there are things that are beyond their control that might go wrong, and things might not happen, but they’re just there to provide the technical help. Which is, I think, a lot of the formal communication around NGO involvement comes down to as technical implementation partners, right?
RAJAGOPALAN: Yes.
GHOSH: You talk about resource constraints here. I think there are a couple of examples that I cover in the paper. One is when a bureaucrat is literally like, “Hey, that school has only one teacher. They are really short of personnel. I don’t think we’ll be able to pull this off there.” This NGO grassroots worker is saying that, “That’s alright. They just need to do this part. At least if they do this part, we’ll have something.” It kind of shows that, somewhere, the NGO worker does not have a lot of control over fixing personnel issues in schools.
RAJAGOPALAN: Yes.
GHOSH: Right? They can even be—
RAJAGOPALAN: I read it as they have zero control over fixing—
GHOSH: Exactly.
RAJAGOPALAN: —personnel issues, right?
GHOSH: Yes, yes.
RAJAGOPALAN: OK. Sorry. Keep going.
GHOSH: Including the NGO at the top, which has signed the MOU with the state. The MOU is for implementing NIPUN and not increasing personnel in schools. I think somewhere the NGOs top to down are aware that that is beyond their locus of control. And I find that at a grassroots level, there is an active—and this is a mix of both changing the topic in some way to a different aspect. But also, at the same time, it could be read as a form of deliberation where these actors are trying to do best with what’s already there instead of waiting for things to get fixed to make things happen.
There’s another case where this group of teachers is actually complaining to one of these grassroots workers that, “Sir, you expect us to teach using these materials, but this year’s new materials have just not arrived. There’s some delay with the printing, and we can’t start classes.” This NGO worker goes into a different zone where he says that, “You could still do without those materials. There’s are a lot of other things you could do with the existing stuff in your classroom.” Then towards the end, he’s like, “Well, you haven’t really completed last year’s materials, so maybe start with that.”
I think, again, this is a scenario where the grassroots worker knows that he does not have much agency over provision of those materials, but again, trying to do best with what’s there. But it could also be interpreted the other way, where they’re shifting the topic, changing the foundation of the discussion so as to maintain their status as experts. Because if the conversation happens around supply and resources, they won’t be the experts anymore. By default, they are the ones who have no control over things. So, trying to keep the conversation going on fronts where they can continue maintaining their status as experts.
RAJAGOPALAN: Coming back to their status as experts or technical helpers, in the paper, when you look at all these three different approaches, you describe it as political labor, even though one aspect explicitly is depoliticization. But what is it about these workers that they are interfacing almost politically as opposed to technically, right? Which makes me think that there is a different way to think about this entire system. You can’t just plug in and plug out technical expertise. You can’t supplement them with a chatbot or something like that, or with an AI-enabled teacher mentor. There is something very specific going on here. So, if you can, walk us through a little bit of that color.
GHOSH: You’re right in pointing out the irony of how these actors are explicitly depoliticizing while being political, as I argue. I still remember a conversation with the leadership of EduFirst in their office in a Tier-1 Indian city. The senior manager in the organization was telling me that, “Oh, we try to be apolitical. We don’t want to get into the politics of it. It’s really sensitive, especially with state-NGO relationships. At this time in India, we don’t want to be political or overtly political.”
Yet, where I see their work as political, again goes back to the first part. These actors, these NGOs, they are explicitly using power in a way in their day-to-day actions to make things happen. They are engaging with the same practices that the state has used over time. They are also identifying the practices the state has used over time and differentiating from that. I think somewhere in this, the political part is more related to decision-making. I’m seeing politics here not as a political party kind of politics, but politics as decision-making that’s driven by certain kinds of incentives, institutional norms, motives, and so on.
To that extent, I find that what these grassroots workers are doing is not just, as you said, technical plugins. They’re coming in, making very strategic, calculated decisions in order to get things done from these different actors, while also maintaining their own status and image and their organization status and image in the larger political economy of education in the state of Vidyapur.
Citizen Advocacy or Substitute for State Capacity?
RAJAGOPALAN: When we are now thinking of this political labor, is this political labor building state capacity? Is it supplementing state capacity in places where there are gaps or it’s lacking? Is it substituting state capacity? That is literally doing the work that government should have been doing, but they are short-staffed. Or is this a completely different element, which has not really got that much to do with state capacity? It’s more about citizen advocacy, which is a different layer that interfaces with the state. What is a good way to think about what these workers are doing?
GHOSH: Yes. I think, again, going back to one of the core arguments that I’m making through this paper, that the boundaries between the state and the nonstate in this case is very porous. I think the conventional way of how we’ve thought of the state and nonstate actors collaborating on work, I think some of the categorizations that you mentioned fit in really well if we think of these actors as separate actors, right?
You think of a nonstate actor and they are building the capacity of the state, which inherently assumes there is a distinction between who the state is, like there’s a boundary of the state. So, what I’m trying to get at is all of those are happening, and yet none of those are happening in a way that—I think those boundaries of the state are not as rigid anymore.
A lot of the informal, authoritative decision-making, but also some of the more humane, relational decision-making, those are really troubling our existing notions of who the state is, what the state usually does, how the state has been. So, if you think of a typical stereotypical bureaucrat, a state bureaucrat in India, as many, many scholars have highlighted and identified over decades, if you think about the authoritative enforcement piece of these grassroots workers, they fit into the same category. But if you think of the more entrepreneurial persuasion part, it’s a completely new strategy. It’s very unusual for someone to be embedded in a state system and be more relationally driven in acting with teachers.
In some ways, the work of NGO grassroots workers at these levels, they are supplementing what the state is trying to do. I think in some ways they are also building models for the state to then replicate. I think there’s a lot of literature on how NGOs have actually enhanced state capacity by enabling mimicry of practices. But I think at the same time, there’s also something much larger going on in terms of who the state thinks NGO is and who NGOs think the state is. [laughter] It’s a very Hum Aapke Hai Koun..! [transl: Who am I to you?] situation, which I think is getting at probably a new dimension of how we study state and nonstate and their interfacing.
RAJAGOPALAN: This is the best movie reference that has popped up so far [laughter] in this kind of development work. The element of what you are telling me—largely, I think none of what you’re telling me is a problem because clearly there is something broken, and we need to start experimenting with these different systems to see what works. But the only concerning part I have is where does accountability sit when you have these kinds of workers who are technically not part of the state but are doing some state functions or are supplementing some state functions and also somehow manage to get the authority to tell government workers what they are supposed to do, right?
Now, let me go one step further, which is beyond the scope of your paper. With a program like NIPUN, I think it’s much less of a problem because this is literally literacy and numeracy. But if it became a little bit more expanded than that, I don’t know if it’s ideal to have local NGO workers train teachers on what is appropriate to be taught in schools and not be taught in schools.
I live in the United States, and there are many debates here about whether creationism or evolution needs to be taught in schools. I’m not sure local NGO workers are the best to either dictate to state workers or to teachers and nudge this thing around. How do you think about accountability and some of these more scary things beyond the scope of NIPUN?
GHOSH: Yes. It’s a really difficult question that I think I wrestled with during the course of fieldwork and I still continue wrestling with. I think when I approach the study normatively, I agree. There’s some part where I see what NGOs are doing, acting just like the state to get things done. There are parts that offer optimism and promise.
But I think this part around accountability again puts me in a similar gray area where I think three things. One is in terms of quality control. As I said earlier, when these MOUs are signed, there’s not an explicit quality-control mechanism that the state has to decide who to sign the MOU with. Someone at the state level who’s signing the MOU is doing so on the basis of relational affinity rather than some kind of expertise, which brings into it a larger question around can we have quality-control mechanisms in place? Can we think of it maybe in terms of how the government regulates private schools? I would preface it by saying struggles to regulate private schools. But can there be provisions put in place which are legalistic but also hold NGOs to some kind of accountability mechanism?
I think the second part, and this is, again, moving away from the state, is in terms of the public. A lot of these NGOs, they’re not working in low-fee private schools or private schools. They’re working in public education funded by taxpayers’ money, attended by people from some of the most marginalized communities in India. When we tend to think of government systems and their provision of education, we often think of accountability mechanisms through, let’s say, Hirschman’s exit, voice, loyalty, and that zone. But if you think of these NGOs through those lenses, no one in the public actually elected these NGOs to help out with these reforms. No one in the public gets to say in who the state signs an MOU with, when that ends, what the terms of it are. The opaque nature of the MOUs makes it even more difficult.
At the same time, I think from an NGO lens, a lot of these NGOs are largely accountable to their donors because most of them are donor-funded. Some of these donors are corporate CSRs in India itself. Some of them are international philanthropic bodies that are putting their money in creating some kind of developmental change.
I think it’s a very nervous zone where who is who accountable to? Who is the state accountable to? Who are these NGOs accountable to if the state does not have any regulatory mechanism, the public has no say in it, but it’s only the donors who can hold them accountable? It creates what a really complex political economy of accountability.
RAJAGOPALAN: That’s super helpful.
GHOSH: I think some of my future work is trying to understand this more from an NGO lens on how they are sustaining themselves within this network. But I think it’s still an uncomfortable position that I continue to wrestle with.
Policy Implications
RAJAGOPALAN: Yes, and I imagine you’re not alone. The closer you get to some of these things, the more it gets a bit uncomfortable and vague. But thank you so much for doing this. This paper is absolutely fascinating. It gives me a very clean peek into this world. Before I let you go, is there any very specific policy suggestion or implication that’s coming out of your work in terms of what the governments or NGOs should do differently?
GHOSH: Yes. I think in terms of the government, what I just shared, I think there needs to be a rethink about not just regulation. I think the government right now, with respect to NGOs, has a lot of problematic regulatory mechanisms like FCRA and all going on. I think there’s been a lot of backlash, and rightly so, in terms of the government cutting off funding for some NGOs which the government felt are not in [the] national interest and so on. I think that’s an area where the government is more regulatory in terms of preserving a larger national moment that we find ourselves in right now.
But I think with respect to quality control, there might be places where the state can actually build in more mechanisms in selecting who to work with, what to work with on. What that looks like remains to be seen. But I think just like the state has tried to do with private schools in India, I think there’s an opportunity to do some of that even if they lose with NGOs in India.
I think from the NGOs’ perspective, I often go back to my days when I was working with an NGO and the thought that eventually the goal is, at least in education, is that children should learn, they should do well, they should feel safe coming to schools. There are holistic outcomes for everyone in part. In some way, there was also this goal of building state capacity. As these NGOs are participating in collaborations with the state, there is a need to build that state capacity. I personally see NGOs should position themselves a lot like, I think, the dating app, Hinge. I think the tagline of Hinge is “designed to be deleted.” And so, the idea is that you install it so that you eventually delete it. That’s the goal met.
RAJAGOPALAN: I didn’t know that, actually. That’s such a lovely thing. [laughter]
GHOSH: Yes, yes. I think somewhere NGOs need to start thinking about their work like that. Their core fundamental role is to get deleted eventually, to work till long enough to build the state’s capacity so that they are not needed there to supplement it anymore.
RAJAGOPALAN: Yes. No, that’s super useful. The Hinge thing, one, it tells you what generation I am [laughter] that I have no clue what Hinge’s tagline is or what it looks like or what its purpose is. But that’s actually exactly right. It’s an excellent way of thinking about it. In an ideal world, we shouldn’t need programs like NIPUN because our schools would be doing that task already. And eventually, even if we do need programs like NIPUN, maybe the support structure that is coming in ,or to think about it in terms of training wheels; at some point, we’ve got to take the training wheels off the state. This was really very interesting for me to read. Thank you so much for doing this, Abhinav. It’s such a pleasure to have you.
GHOSH: Thank you so much, Shruti. This was a great, great conversation. Thank you so much.