January 1, 2006

An Orphan Works Affirmative Defense to Copyright Infringement Actions

  • Jerry Brito

    Former Senior Research Fellow
  • Bridget C. E. Dooling

Key materials
Contact us
To speak with a scholar or learn more on this topic, visit our contact page.

The Regulation

  • The Copyright Office has submitted a report to Congress outlining the extent of the orphan works problem and recommending a legislative solution.
  • Orphan works are creative works the authors of which cannot be ascertained. If a work's copyright owner cannot be found to secure their permission to use the work, then no one will ultimately use the work lest they risk liability for copyright infringement.

Our Findings

  • The orphan works problem is real and it is preventing a large portion of existing literary, artistic, and other works from being preserved or used in derivative works.
  • Several solutions to this problem have been suggested, but most proposals are cumbersome or incompatible with political and legal reality.

Recommendations

  • We propose a new orphan works affirmative defense to infringement actions similar to the fair use affirmative defense.
  • If, after a reasonable search in good faith, no copyright holder for a work is found, the work may be used without the user being subject to liability.
  • As with the fair use statute, there should be a codified non-exclusive list of factors that a court will consider in determining whether the user-defendant carried out a reasonable search in good faith.